From Sacred Ritual to Seasonal Spectacle in Late Capitalism
▶️ Rave the World Radio
24/7 electronic music streaming from around the globe
Introduction: When Christmas Knows It Is Plastic
Christmas today often feels oddly self-aware. The blinking LEDs, inflatable Santas, ironic sweaters, retro vinyl soundtracks, minimalist Scandinavian ornaments, and hyper-commercial advertising all seem to know they are artificial — and they don’t even try to hide it. This knowing artificiality is precisely where postmodernism and Christmas kitsch meet.
Postmodernism is not simply a historical period or artistic style; it is a cultural condition marked by irony, quotation, pastiche, fragmentation, and a deep suspicion toward grand narratives. Christmas kitsch, meanwhile, refers to sentimental, excessive, mass-produced holiday aesthetics that privilege emotional immediacy over depth or authenticity. When combined, they produce a peculiar phenomenon: a holiday that simultaneously mocks itself, markets itself, and desperately seeks meaning through repetition.
This essay explores how Christmas kitsch becomes a postmodern object — how it functions aesthetically, economically, psychologically, and politically — and why its artificial glow continues to feel comforting in an increasingly unstable world.
1. What Is Kitsch, and Why Christmas Is Its Perfect Habitat
Kitsch is traditionally understood as art or design that is overly sentimental, formulaic, and designed for mass appeal. It prioritizes emotional effect over complexity and reassurance over challenge. Think porcelain angels, snow globes, glittery reindeer, canned carols, and syrupy imagery of eternal family harmony.
Christmas is uniquely suited to kitsch for several reasons:
It is cyclical and repetitive, returning every year with predictable rituals.
It is emotionally charged, linked to childhood, nostalgia, and memory.
It is visually codified, with instantly recognizable symbols.
It is commercially central, embedded in consumer capitalism.
Kitsch thrives where familiarity is rewarded and ambiguity is punished. Christmas offers exactly that: a closed symbolic system where deviation is possible but must still remain recognizable. Even rebellion — black Christmas trees, ironic ornaments, minimalist anti-Christmas aesthetics — still references the original script.
2. Postmodernism: Irony, Simulation, and the End of the Original
Postmodernism challenges the idea of originality, authenticity, and universal truth. Instead, it celebrates remix, quotation, surface, and play. In a postmodern world:
Everything is a copy of a copy.
Meaning is unstable and contextual.
High culture and low culture collapse into one another.
Irony becomes a dominant mode of engagement.
Christmas in this context no longer needs to be true or sincere — it only needs to be recognizable. A plastic tree is not pretending to be real; it is a sign of a tree. A mall Santa is not Saint Nicholas; he is a simulation of a simulation.
This aligns closely with the postmodern concept of hyperreality, where representations become more real than what they represent. For many people, the cinematic, decorated, curated version of Christmas feels more real than any historical or religious origin.
3. The Self-Aware Ornament: Irony as Emotional Shield
One of the defining features of postmodern Christmas kitsch is irony. Ugly sweaters are worn because they are ugly. Inflatable decorations are chosen because they are excessive. Retro kitsch is recycled knowingly, with a wink.
This irony serves several functions:
It protects against disappointment: if Christmas fails, at least we were joking.
It allows participation without belief.
It transforms consumption into performance.
Irony becomes an emotional shield in a world where sincerity feels risky. Loving Christmas too much risks naivety; hating it risks isolation. Irony offers a third path: affectionate detachment.
Yet irony is not neutral. Over time, it can hollow out meaning, replacing belief with endless reference. The joke must be repeated every year — louder, brighter, more exaggerated — to feel anything at all.
4. Capitalism Wrapped in Tinsel
Christmas kitsch is inseparable from late capitalism. Seasonal consumption is not a side effect; it is the engine. Decorations, gifts, experiences, and emotions are all commodified.
Postmodern capitalism excels at absorbing critique. Anti-consumer Christmas messages become products. Minimalist aesthetics become luxury brands. Sustainability becomes a marketing category. Even nostalgia itself is packaged and sold.
This produces a paradox:
We know it’s commercial.
We criticize it.
We participate anyway.
The result is a ritual without transcendence but with repetition — a simulation of meaning that functions socially even when belief fades.
5. Religion as Aesthetic Residue
In postmodern Christmas kitsch, religious symbols often remain, but emptied of theological weight. Angels become decorative motifs. Nativity scenes become quaint installations. Sacred narratives are flattened into atmosphere.
This does not necessarily signal hostility toward religion, but rather a shift from belief to ambiance. The sacred survives as style.
For secular societies, this aesthetic residue performs an important role: it allows participation in tradition without requiring faith. Christmas becomes cultural rather than doctrinal — a shared visual language rather than a shared metaphysics.
6. Nostalgia Without Memory
Postmodern Christmas kitsch is obsessed with nostalgia — often for times never personally experienced. Vintage ornaments, 1950s aesthetics, imagined childhoods, and cinematic memories replace lived history.
This is nostalgia without memory: a longing not for the past, but for the idea of the past.
In unstable economic and ecological conditions, this backward gaze provides comfort. It suggests continuity in a world of disruption. Even if the memory is fictional, the feeling is real.
7. Why Some Still Need It
Despite its artificiality, Christmas kitsch persists because it fulfills real psychological and social needs:
Predictability in chaotic times
Shared rituals in fragmented societies
Permission to feel tenderness
Temporary suspension of cynicism
Postmodernism does not destroy meaning; it reveals how meaning is constructed. Christmas kitsch, knowingly fake yet emotionally effective, demonstrates that humans can attach genuine feeling to artificial forms.
The problem is not kitsch itself, but the absence of alternative rituals that offer depth without exclusion.
Conclusion: Plastic, Glowing, and Still Ours
Postmodern Christmas kitsch is neither purely cynical nor purely sincere. It is a cultural compromise: a way to keep tradition alive when belief is fractured, community is unstable, and authenticity is contested.
It glows not because it is profound, but because it is familiar. It repeats not because it convinces, but because it comforts.
In that sense, Christmas kitsch is one of postmodernism’s most honest artifacts: openly artificial, emotionally effective, and quietly revealing of what we still long for.
References
Baudrillard, Jean. Simulacra and Simulation
Jameson, Fredric. Postmodernism, or, The Cultural Logic of Late Capitalism
Kundera, Milan. The Unbearable Lightness of Being (on kitsch)
Benjamin, Walter. The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction
Eco, Umberto. Travels in Hyperreality
Comments
Post a Comment